What’s he pondering? Newest scandal places highlight on Trudeau’s moral compass

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau finds himself going through formal allegations of unethical behaviour for the third time, many Canadians have only one query.

What’s he pondering?


The federal ethics commissioner is probing claims federal funding was granted to a charity at whose occasions Trudeau’s relations have been paid to talk.

A number of members of Trudeau’s fast household — together with his spouse, Sophie Grégoire Trudeau — had been collectively paid $283,400 to talk at occasions hosted by WE Charity, the identical group just lately chosen to ship a $900-million volunteering grant program.

This newest scandal comes a yr after Trudeau was discovered to have violated conflict-of-interest guidelines for his function within the SNC-Lavalin affair, and three years after he did the identical by vacationing on a non-public island owned by the Aga Khan.


So what’s it that continues to guide this prime minister into moral sizzling water?

Observers have many, many alternative theories.

Lori Turnbull, the director of the College of Public Administration at Dalhousie College, mentioned that from her viewpoint, there are two choices: Both the prime minister genuinely didn’t assume that his actions had been that dangerous, or he was taking a calculated danger that, with the Conservatives nonetheless leaderless, he’d win an election anyway.


“The necessary level, I believe, ought to be, does the prime minister really feel accountable for his actions?” Turnbull mentioned.

Turnbull questioned whether or not a part of the difficulty is Trudeau’s uncommon upbringing — the truth that he had celeb mates and a world model lengthy earlier than he was voted into probably the most highly effective workplace within the nation.


“Prime Minister Trudeau had achieved this earlier than; he lived at 24 Sussex earlier than, he has method cooler mates than the remainder of us,” Turnbull mentioned, nothing that each the present scandal and the one concerned the Aga Khan could possibly be seen as his lack of ability to untangle his private life from his new skilled one.

“I don’t assume it forgives it,” Turnbull mentioned, “however I believe he doesn’t essentially understand that one thing that appears completely innocuous to him raises eyebrows for different folks.”

Ann Skeet, senior director of management ethics at Santa Clara College’s Markkula Heart for Utilized ethics, mentioned it’s true that everybody makes moral errors — typically stemming from blind spots and lack of expertise. She additionally pointed to the truth that Trudeau was born into privilege, saying he might not have had as many alternatives to purpose by a few of these points.


However every particular person develops their moral conscience over time — and after three critical, and really completely different alleged moral infractions, she mentioned — it’s honest for Canadians to start out asking what Trudeau is doing to enhance his personal.

Skeet mentioned that if she had been a part of the management group throughout the Liberal social gathering, she could be dissatisfied in Trudeau’s decision-making and urgently asking how it may be improved — or a minimum of positioned in examine.

“You’re the prime minister of a significant nation, a G8 nation, you’ve gotten an rising profile, perhaps partially as a result of our personal management within the U.S. is turning into much less influential,” she mentioned.


“It is best to at this level get it that individuals are watching what you do.”

Pamela Ennis, a Toronto-based industrial psychologist who each screens and coaches senior executives, says that whereas the enterprise world has grown extra acutely aware of issues equivalent to ethics lately — dangerous behaviour is dangerous for the underside line — the identical stress isn’t all the time utilized within the political sphere.

Get extra of what issues in your inbox

Begin your morning with all the things it’s worthwhile to know, and nothing you do not. Join First Up, the Star’s new each day electronic mail publication.


Sign Up Now

Whereas she wouldn’t touch upon Trudeau’s actions, she mentioned it’s not unusual to work with executives who’re good, bold and pushed, however who’ve a blind spot with regards to the views of different folks.

“What I’m speaking about is a really unilateral, nearly ‘my method or the freeway’ model of management the place ‘I’m proper, you’re mistaken, and I don’t care.’”


In these circumstances, she mentioned, she coaches them on self perception, with the final word purpose that they’d have the ability to assume extra typically about how their actions have an effect on others.

Skeet added community of formal advisers goes a good distance — individuals who can level out moral issues that will not be instantly obvious to a person.

Many commentators have questioned publicly about why nobody inside Trudeau’s camp has been in a position to head off these potential moral lapses.


Within the case of the WE scandal, Skeet mentioned, “It may have been a real perception that he needed to transfer rapidly, couldn’t take time to seek the advice of lots of people,” she mentioned. “However what you hope is that he’s surrounding himself with folks that say: ‘Wait, however haven’t your spouse and mom been paid by this group?’ And if not — why?”

One other query now, is will this third scandal do what the primary two arguably didn’t, and keep on with Trudeau?

Turnbull argues that it simply may.


“In a variety of the research about Canadian attitudes about ethics, it’s the little issues,” she mentioned.

“It’s the minister who ordered a $16 glass of orange juice as a result of she may,” she mentioned, referring to the virtually canonical Canadian scandal that took down former cupboard minister Bev Oda in 2012.


“It’s that sort of like each day life sort of stuff. … It pisses folks off much more than folks assume.”

Alex Boyd

Alex Boyd is a Calgary-based reporter for the Star. Observe her on Twitter: @alex.n.boydAlex McKeen is a Vancouver-based reporter protecting transportation and labour for the Star. Observe her on Twitter: @alex_mckeen