A 75-year-old man suffered a head harm and is in ‘steady however critical situation’ after he was shoved by police throughout a protest in Buffalo, New York.



ALBANY, N.Y. – Two suspended Buffalo cops have been charged with second-degree assault Saturday amid outcry over video showing officers shoving a 75-year-old man to the bottom, Erie County District Legal professional John Flynn mentioned in a information convention.

Officers Robert McCabe and Aaron Torgalski pleaded not responsible to the feesand have been anticipated again in court docket July 20 for a felony listening to, based on Flynn’s workplace.

All 57 of the members of the Buffalo Police Division’s Emergency Response Staff resigned from the unit Friday after the 2 officers have been suspended. The unit members haven’t stop the police division however have stepped down from the tactical unit.


Legal professional Kelly V. Zarcone issued an announcement from Martin Gugino, the man who was pushed to the bottom, saying Gugino is “a longtime peaceable protester, human rights advocate, and general fan of the US Structure.”

Gugino is in “critical however steady situation. He’s alert and oriented,” Zarcone mentioned within the emailed assertion. He requests privateness and that future protests stay peaceable.

Graphic video from WBFO reveals the 2 officers pushing Gugino down as he approached them in a public sq. round an eight p.m. curfew Thursday. Gugino stumbles again and falls, and the video reveals him immobile and bleeding from his head.


“Our place is these officers have been merely following orders from Deputy Police Commissioner Joseph Gramaglia to clear the sq.,” Buffalo Police Benevolent Affiliation President John Evans mentioned. “It does not specify clear the sq. of males, 50 and beneath or 15 to 40. They have been merely doing their job. I do not understand how a lot contact was made. He did slip in my estimation. He fell backwards.”

Requested concerning the resigning officers at a press convention that afternoon, Erie County Government Mark Poloncarz he can be “upset” if they’d in reality resigned.

“In the event that they resigned, I am exceptionally upset by it as a result of it signifies to me that they didn’t see something mistaken with the actions final night time,” Poloncarz mentioned.


The officer’s actions shortly drew condemnation from across the state, together with Gov. Andrew Cuomo who said the “incident is wholly unjustified and totally disgraceful.”

Throughout a press briefing Friday, Cuomo performed video of the incident, watching it wide-eyed earlier than questioning the officers’ actions.


“You see that video and it disturbs your primary sense of decency and humanity,” Cuomo mentioned.

“Why? Why? Why was that crucial? The place was the risk? It was an older gentleman. The place was the risk? And then you definately simply stroll by the particular person while you see blood coming from his head,” he mentioned, describing the scene.

U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer known as for an investigation, based on an announcement reported by WIVB-TV.


“The informal cruelty demonstrated by Buffalo cops tonight is gut-wrenching and unacceptable,” John Curr, the Buffalo chapter director for the New York Civil Liberties Union, mentioned in an announcement, including that it needs to be a “wake-up name” for metropolis leaders to deal with police violence. 

In its preliminary assertion on the incident, the Buffalo Police Division mentioned an individual “was injured when he tripped & fell,” WIVB-TV reported. A later statement posted on the department’s Facebook page mentioned two officers had been suspended with out pay and an inside affairs investigation was underway. 

Mayor Byron Brown said in a statement that he and town’s police commissioner have been “deeply disturbed by the video.” Brown additionally confirmed the officers’ suspension and inside affairs investigation.


“After days of peaceable protests and several other conferences between myself, police management and members of the neighborhood, tonight’s occasion is disheartening,” Brown mentioned.

Brown launched an announcement Friday saying that town was conscious of “developments associated to the work assignments of sure members of the Buffalo police power.”

Contingency plans have been in place to make sure public security, Brown mentioned.


5 protesters have been arrested for disorderly conduct, based on NBC affiliate WGRZ-TV. Not one of the cops seen within the video has been criminally charged.

The Buffalo Police Division and the New York State Police didn’t instantly reply to USA TODAY’s requests for touch upon Thursday.

“I can guarantee you, Martin is a peaceful particular person,” mentioned Vicki Ross, govt director of Western New York Peace Middle and Latin American Solidarity Committee, a company Gugino was concerned with.


“There isn’t any method that he was doing something to accost or damage. He made a judgment to remain out after the curfew as a result of he feels that our civil liberties are so at risk, which they most definitely are.”

Ross mentioned Gugino has been present process chemotherapy for most cancers.

The incident comes after greater than every week of protests in opposition to police brutality following George Floyd’s demise in Minneapolis. Floyd, who’s black, died after now-fired police officer, who’s white, pressed his knee into Floyd’s neck for almost 9 minutes as different officers stood by.


Since Floyd’s demise, which has been dominated a murder, protesters nationwide have decried police brutality and racial inequality. Some protests have been marred by violence and looting, and police have been caught on digital camera a number of occasions utilizing power in opposition to protesters – together with peaceable ones.

Contributing: Sarah Taddeo and Grace Hauck, USA TODAY; Marcia Greenwood, Democrat and Chronicle; The Related Press


Present Thumbnails


Present Captions

Learn or Share this story: