Toronto program serving to undocumented employees axed after Authorized Help funding cuts

For the previous three years, a Toronto authorized clinic undertaking to assist undocumented employees dealing with wage theft and generally life-changing office accidents has wrestled with a puzzle: how do you attain individuals who worry being reached?

However with simply $150,000 a 12 months to deal with the issue, the Centre for Spanish Talking Peoples’ Buena Paga program managed to assist tons of of the town’s most weak employees by way of authorized help, a radio present on office rights, coaching and job gala’s. This system additionally gained employees a median of over $10,000 a month in unpaid entitlements.

Whereas specializing in Spanish-speaking undocumented employees, Buena Paga lawyer and co-ordinator Gloria Carrasquero says the initiative aimed to assist “everybody who was knocking on our door,” no matter the place they lived, their standing in Canada, or their mom tongue. Now, following Authorized Help cuts introduced in April, the initiative has been axed — and Carrasquero and two different members of the Buena Paga workforce are out of a job.

“It’s actually upsetting to me that it is a program that’s being minimize, when it was clearly simply so efficient in so some ways,” mentioned Mary Ellen McIntyre, the CSSP’s authorized clinic director.

This system began in 2016 as a result of the Ministry of Labour observed an uptick in complaints from Spanish-speaking employees, a few of whom had been undocumented, she added. The ministry supplied two years-worth of funding for the clinic to create Buena Paga — which suggests well-paid in Spanish — and supply training about rights on the job. Authorized Help Ontario took over the funding in 2018.

Earlier this 12 months the Ford authorities minimize Legal Aid Ontario’s budget, beforehand anticipated to be $456-million, by 30 per cent. Because of this, LAO is lowering funds for authorized clinics by round $14.5 million this 12 months.

Undocumented employees are entitled to safety by provincial labour legal guidelines and the employees’ compensation system, however “most undocumented employees imagine they haven’t any rights in any respect, they haven’t any safety in any respect,” mentioned Daniel Rippes, a lawyer with the CSSP’s authorized clinic.

“You’ll be shocked that even some authorities businesses have no idea that they’re entitled to primary entitlements.”


Along with working a weekly radio program offering info on employees rights, this system supplied twice weekly workshops and operated a devoted telephone line for employees to name with employment points. It additionally hosted month-to-month “espresso home” periods that mixed music and leisure with training about office protections, attended by round 100 employees each month.

Buena Paga’s authorized work has additionally helped implement primary rights for employees, a few of whom are undocumented. Others don’t converse sufficient English to navigate the authorized system alone.

Learn extra:

Trudeau vows to protect vulnerable people as Ottawa commits $26M for legal aid after Ontario funding cut

Toronto courts a ‘confusing mess’ as legal aid cuts leave some accused without representation, lawyers say

Opinion | Cuts to legal clinics a sinister plan to harm the most vulnerable

One employee, who the Star isn’t naming as a result of his settlement is topic to a nondisclosure settlement, mentioned he labored for a development firm for over a decade, working 10 hours a day, six days per week. However when he turned 60, his boss began pressuring him to retire — giving him paperwork to signal that he didn’t perceive and at one level grew to become bodily aggressive with the employee. With Buena Paga’s assist, the employee was capable of win a number of thousand in a wrongful dismissal case.

“I used to be working good, I beloved my job,” mentioned the employee, who’s initially from Ecuador the place he educated as an architect. “(My boss) trusted me. He modified as a result of I’m previous.”


It’s tough to estimate the variety of undocumented employees in Toronto, however nationwide the determine has been positioned wherever between 200,000 to 500,000. Round half are believed to stay within the Larger Toronto Space, typically working within the development and cleansing sectors. In 2013, the Metropolis of Toronto declared itself a Sanctuary Metropolis after noting whereas undocumented employees “contribute to the Canadian economic system by paying for primary wants of shelter, meals and different companies, in addition to paying provincial gross sales tax,” they typically face “a number of limitations to residing wholesome fulfilling lives.”

“They’re significantly vulnerable to conditions the place they’re required to work for low wages, beneath poor and unsafe work circumstances, and the place they haven’t any safety in opposition to unfair dismissal, abuse and/or exploitation by their employer,” says a workers report from the time.

The town’s coverage means Toronto residents can entry most municipal companies with out offering details about their immigration standing. However a 2017 report by the Ryerson Centre for Immigration and Settlement discovered these measures had not been “successfully applied” as a consequence of insufficient entrance line coaching and poor outreach to related communities.

That, mentioned Carrasquero, is what made Buena Paga so distinctive.

Get extra of the Star in your inbox

By no means miss the most recent information from the Star. Join our newsletters to get at the moment’s high tales, your favorite columnists and plenty extra in your inbox

Sign Up Now

“(Staff) don’t have another place the place they’ll discover this info,” she mentioned.

“The Buena Paga workforce have confirmed that they can attain essentially the most weak members of their very own racialized communities; employees that non-LatinX authorized workers at different clinics had not beforehand been capable of entry,” mentioned the CSSP’s background report on the undertaking from July.

Though Authorized Help Ontario authorised Buena Paga’s funding late final 12 months, the cash was dispersed by way of a associate authorized clinic, the Staff’ Well being and Security Authorized Clinic (WHSLC), which LAO hit with a $240,000 minimize to its price range — ensuing within the elimination of Buena Paga.

In response to questions from the Star, LAO spokesperson Graeme Burk mentioned whereas the group minimize WHSLC’s price range, it “didn’t particularly cut back funding for the Buena Paga initiative.”

“Moderately, the choice to finish the Buena Paga program was made by the board of the WHSLC,” he mentioned, including that clinics’ board of administrators are “answerable for figuring out the authorized wants of people and communities.”

On Monday, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau introduced a one-time $26.eight million high up for LAO to deal with refugee and immigration instances. McIntyre says the funding increase is unlikely to save lots of Buena Paga.

Along with serving to employees, McIntyre says this system was about shifting tradition in a shadow economic system the place some employers intentionally rent undocumented employees as a result of “screwing them” is less complicated.

“To me, one of many greatest successes of this system that (Rippes) has acquired employers phoning him up saying, ‘I wish to do the precise factor.’ Clearly we are able to’t advise employers, however we are able to dialogue. And that’s tradition,” she mentioned.

McIntyre mentioned she continues to be hopeful that organizations within the metropolis will step as much as rescue this system. Gustavo Vega, who gained $1,600 in unpaid termination pay due to Buena Paga’s help, mentioned he hopes so too — including that he used a few of his personal settlement cash to make a donation to this system.

“The cash is absolutely essential as a result of I’m a low-income particular person,” he mentioned. “However the primary factor was that I used to be capable of combat for my rights.”

With recordsdata from Jacques Gallant

Sara Mojtehedzadeh is a Toronto-based reporter masking labour-related points. Comply with her on Twitter: @saramojtehedz