Profiling class motion towards Montreal police a ‘victory for justice,’ group says

MONTREAL—For years, members of Montreal’s Black group have informed tales in regards to the discrimination they’ve allegedly suffered by the hands of town police: A Black lawyer in a BMW, repeatedly pulled over. A person checking his cellphone on the road, questioned and ultimately arrested. Seemingly routine police interventions that escalate to violence and even loss of life.

On Tuesday, the top of the Black Coalition of Quebec mentioned that after a long time of getting their claims largely ignored, a class-action lawsuit towards the Metropolis of Montreal affords an opportunity for justice.

“For greater than 40 years, now we have been seeking to give the individuals some semblance of justice … and we find yourself being thrown apart,” mentioned Dan Philip, the group’s president.

“They are saying you may’t win something, and as we speak now we have, and that’s for the primary time — not solely in Quebec, however in Canada,” he mentioned, calling the choice “historic.”

Sitting at a desk within the group’s workplace, beneath posters of such figures as Muhammad Ali, Nelson Mandela and Barack Obama, in entrance of a white candle meant to represent hope, Philip and two different members of the group expressed hope that the lawsuit would result in change.

On Aug. 7, a Quebec Superior Courtroom choose approved a category motion towards Montreal on behalf of residents who allege they had been unfairly arrested, detained and racially profiled by town’s police between mid-August 2017 and January 2019.

In his ruling, Justice Andre Prevost mentioned the category motion would tackle quite a lot of questions, together with whether or not metropolis representatives acted in a discriminatory vogue and violated the rights of the plaintiffs.

Whereas he dominated that the claimants had sufficient proof to proceed, the allegations contained within the lawsuit will nonetheless must be confirmed in courtroom.


Philip acknowledged that Prevost’s choice is simply step one in prolonged authorized course of, nevertheless it nonetheless sends a strong message.

“This isn’t only a victory for the Black group, it’s also a victory for justice,” he mentioned.

Philip mentioned the category motion can also be vital to indicate how town’s leaders sided with authorities as a substitute of assembly their duty to guard seen minorities.

“The Metropolis of Montreal, in all of the circumstances of abuse and discrimination towards the Black group, has all the time contested the justified actions of the Black group who’re victims of discrimination and racial profiling,” he mentioned.

Town has to date declined to touch upon Prevost’s choice, saying the matter is earlier than the courts.


Gabriel Bazin, the coalition’s vice-president, mentioned members of Montreal’s Black and cultural communities have suffered routine harassment and profiling.

He cited the case of lead plaintiff Alexandre Lamontagne, a person of Haitian origin who claims that in August 2017 he was standing on the road checking his cellphone when he was questioned by two law enforcement officials. He was arrested and charged with obstructing police work and assault with the intention of resisting arrest, however the prices had been later dropped.

Jean-Claude Yves, who can also be of Haitian origin, informed reporters on the information convention that he plans to hitch the category motion.

Yves, 54, alleges that in 2017 he was unfairly questioned and accused of robbing a grocery retailer, despite the fact that the bag he was carrying contained solely a Bible. He alleges he needed to make a number of courtroom appearances, solely to be taught that another person had already been arrested for the crime.

He mentioned the arrest left him with each bodily and psychological wounds.

“It gave me numerous stress,” he mentioned. “I needed to fall to the bottom, my brother needed to take me to the hospital.”

The lawsuit is open to anybody who, “following a proactive intervention from a police officer of town of Montreal was stopped, arrested and/or detained with out justification and skilled racial profiling, a violation of their rights as a citizen and/or some other violation of the rights assured by the Canadian Constitution of Rights and Freedoms and/or the Quebec Constitution of Human Rights and Freedoms,” based on Provost’s ruling.

Those that suffered bodily hurt between Aug. 14, 2017 and Jan. 11, 2019 are eligible, whereas those that weren’t bodily harmed can apply if the incident occurred between July 11, 2018, and the closing interval.

Get extra of the Star in your inbox

By no means miss the most recent information from the Star. Join our newsletters to get as we speak’s prime tales, your favorite columnists and plenty extra in your inbox

Sign Up Now

The coalition estimates it’s going to have about 150 individuals becoming a member of the lawsuit, however that quantity might rise. The category motion seeks each compensatory and punitive damages, however Philip on Tuesday declined to say how a lot is being sought.