Dutch euthanasia physician faces verdict in landmark case – Expat Information to The Netherlands


A Dutch court docket will give its verdict Wednesday on a physician accused of euthanising a affected person with extreme dementia in a landmark case within the nation which pioneered the apply.

The unnamed feminine physician, the primary to go on trial underneath a 2002 legislation legalising euthanasia, allegedly did not correctly seek the advice of the 74-year-old who could have modified her thoughts about dying.

Prosecutors have requested judges to not sentence the now-retired physician as she had acted with “good intentions”, including that she had “utterly cooperated” with the probe and already confronted disciplinary measures.

Nonetheless the 68-year-old may nonetheless in idea be discovered responsible of homicide.

The 2016 case attracted media consideration as a result of particulars of how the affected person was given a sedative in her espresso however nonetheless needed to be restrained by her household because the physician injected the euthanasia drug.

The decision shall be an necessary check of the legislation within the nation that was the primary on the planet to legalise euthanasia, adopted shortly afterwards by neighbouring Belgium.

Euthanasia can solely be carried out underneath strict circumstances set down in Dutch legislation, together with that the affected person should have “insufferable and limitless struggling” and have requested to die “earnestly and with full conviction”.

The legislation says medical doctors might also carry out euthanasia if the affected person has lapsed into “semi-consciousness simply earlier than a scheduled euthanasia” and there are nonetheless indicators of struggling.

However prosecutors stated the accused physician, who specialised in geriatric care, “didn’t seek the advice of her affected person sufficient” earlier than going by way of with the method at a care dwelling in The Hague.

– ‘Restrain the affected person’ –

The aged girl was identified 4 years earlier than her loss of life with Alzheimer’s, a illness that steadily robs individuals of their psychological colleges.

She had requested in a written assertion to be euthanised relatively than being put right into a care dwelling for individuals affected by dementia, the prosecutors stated.

However the girl additionally added: “I need to have the ability to resolve (when to die) whereas nonetheless in my senses and once I assume the time is true,” in line with the Dutch Euthanasia Overview Committee (RTE), which critiques each case to make sure that tips had been adopted.

Shortly after the affected person was finally taken into care, the physician judged that she certified for euthanasia, as requested in her assertion. Two unbiased medical doctors confirmed the prognosis.

Prosecutors say the physician didn’t seek the advice of the lady after she was taken into care whether or not she nonetheless needed to undergo with the euthanasia.

On the day of her loss of life, the aged girl was unwittingly given a sedative in her espresso earlier than the physician administered a deadly relaxant within the presence of the affected person’s husband and daughter — who authorized of the transfer.

However the girl stood up whereas the euthanasia drug was being injected, the assessment board stated, including that “the affected person’s household then helped to restrain the affected person and the physician rapidly administered the remainder”.

“A vital query to this case is how lengthy a physician ought to proceed consulting a affected person with dementia, if the affected person in an earlier stage already requested euthanasia,” prosecution service spokeswoman Sanna van der Harg stated.

“The legislation doesn’t give a transparent reply, that’s why we are actually asking a choose on this case,” Van der Harg stated.

Final yr 6,126 individuals had been euthanised within the Netherlands, in line with newest RTE figures.