Coronavirus lockdown sparks a shocking backlash towards otters in Singapore, the ‘Otter Metropolis’

Life was already hardscrabble for the seven river otters often known as the Zouk household.

Prime land subsequent to Singapore’s glowing waterways brimming with fish had been seized by different clans, forcing the hapless group to wander the city-state every day in the hunt for meals and shelter. However few seen their forays till a coronavirus shutdown often known as the circuit breaker was imposed in April.


With the streets practically emptied, the Zouks — named after a neighborhood nightclub — began showing in surprising locations: splashing round in a luxury condominium pool, taking a break outdoors a normally teeming shopping center in Little India and making an attempt to chop by the foyer of a children’s hospital.

All of it appeared somewhat innocent. However requires a crackdown on the otter inhabitants started when the Zouks raided a non-public pond stocked with costly decorative fish on the grounds of a spa owned by a former actress.

“The otters killed all of the fishes within the pond,” Jazreel Low wrote in a Facebook post punctuated by a tragic face emoji and what appears to be like like a surveillance digital camera picture of 4 otters skipping by her briefly shuttered enterprise. Low later posted a picture of her 13-year-old arowana, Ah Huat — which means “to prosper” — in higher occasions.


“Darn otters! They gotta pay for it!” wrote one sympathetic commenter.

Inside days, there have been calls on social media and a radio program to cull the slippery animals. A widely shared letter revealed within the native Straits Occasions advisable deterring otters with air horns and rubber bullets.

“Wild boars have by no means been inspired to enter city areas, neither ought to otters be simply because they appear cute,” wrote Ong Junkai, an aquaculture merchandise salesman.


It was a harsh response, one which otter lovers reasoned was amplified by the need to debate (or complain) about something aside from the coronavirus. It was additionally unanticipated. Singapore appeared a metropolis captivated by the cuddly creatures — a mannequin of coexistence with city wildlife.

Water streams from the Merlion, Singapore’s mythical mascot, in a park near the central business district.

Water streams from the Merlion, Singapore’s legendary mascot, in a park close to the central enterprise district.


(Millie Ball)

Ever since 2014, after they began showing in Marina Bay — the waterfront famed for its Merlion and Marina Bay Sands resort — the otters have been handled like celebrities in a metropolis in any other case often known as the Lion Metropolis.


When requested to vote for a mascot to characterize Singapore throughout its 2016 Nationwide Day festivities, residents overwhelmingly selected the otters.

The animals have been given the David Attenborough documentary remedy and have spawned numerous fan pages, together with the carefully adopted Ottercity, a nerve middle for the bands of native lovers who observe the animal’s actions.

When the patriarch of a beloved household of otters often known as the Bishan 10 died in 2018, mourners drew anthropomorphic classes from the life he led.


“The Bishan dad was capable of hold the household collectively. When he handed away, there was a whole lot of reflection amongst otter watchers about our personal lives and our personal accomplishments,” mentioned Sivasothi N., a biologist on the Nationwide College of Singapore, higher often known as the Otterman due to his experience with the animals.

One thing in regards to the otters’ life-style provokes envy amongst Singapore’s high-achieving and high-strung society.

“They’re precisely who we wish to be,” mentioned Jeffrey Teo, Asia Pacific managing director of a French monetary companies agency and the founding father of Ottercity. “They spend time with household. They wish to swim, eat good meals and perform a little sunbathing.”


The actual fact the otters are even discovered right here, in one of many densest cities on this planet, provokes astonishment. Most species of the semiaquatic animal stay solitary lives.

However Singapore’s prevalent otter, the smooth-coated selection, is unusually social. They swim by row boats, roll within the grass subsequent to vacationers and take dips in reservoirs, whose banks double as jogging paths.

The dramatic Singapore city skyline at sunset


The dramatic Singapore metropolis skyline at sundown, with the putting Marina Bay Sands Resort to the left, three towers with a Skypark atop them.

(MasterLu / Getty Pictures)


“We have now one of the best otter-watching situations on this planet, no query about it,” mentioned Philip Johns, a biologist at Yale-NUS School, who was so taken by the animals when he arrived in Singapore from the U.S. in 2015 that he deserted notions of learning colugos, a gliding nocturnal mammal that appears like a cross between a bat and a lemur.

“Evolutionarily talking, colugos are fascinating,” Johns mentioned. “However they principally sit in timber and do nothing. Otters are like wolves. They’re like coyotes in water.”

As soon as thought extinct right here, just like the Malayan tiger, the otters started reappearing within the 1990s in much less urbanized corners earlier than capturing everybody’s consideration in Marina Bay.


Their return is due partially to a massive clean-up of Singapore’s rivers that started within the 1970s. Dredging of the river backside muck turned up lifeless pigs, canine and chickens. You possibly can scent some rivers earlier than you noticed them. However the restored waters introduced again an otter banquet: tilapia, catfish and all method of unique species, such because the yellow-hued Orinoco peacock bass.

It’s greater than eating, although, that makes Singapore optimum for otters. The diamond-shaped island — roughly the scale of the San Fernando Valley — is etched with a community of drains and canals that type a “subway system for the otters to maneuver round actually, actually shortly,” Johns mentioned.

Mobility is paramount. Otters are fiercely territorial. And now that Singapore’s otter inhabitants has grown to about 90 animals belonging to 10 households, clashes for alternative river banks and fishing waters have grown too.


At first, Singaporeans have been horrified that the furry critters have been able to such ferocious preventing. Some tried to interrupt up squabbles with umbrellas.

Battles usually start with a cacophony of squeals that may escalate into suits of biting. Pups are the one casualties, usually drowned and located floating. About 10 otters died in Singapore final yr from a mixture of preventing and car collisions.

The Zouks have been first pushed from part of the Singapore River. They ended up within the Botanic Backyard however its shallow ponds didn’t present sufficient fish to boost a household. That’s when the Zouks hit the highway.


Their spa jaunt this month wasn’t the primary time otters had made headlines for munching on pets. In 2016, local media reported otters ate tens of hundreds of ’ value of unique fish from non-public ponds on unique Sentosa Island.

Otter consultants recommend constructing extra constrictive fencing and choosing smaller pet fish, which aren’t definitely worth the otters’ consideration. Having a safety guard readily available couldn’t damage both.

That doesn’t fulfill critics like Ong, the writer of the letter to the Straits Occasions, who’s satisfied extra Singaporeans would demand stricter administration of the urbanized otters in the event that they weren’t frightened of a backlash.


“Speaking about controlling them in any manner is sure to attract unfavourable feedback primarily based on emotional response,” mentioned Ong, 38, who has an academic background in biology and biomedical science. He cited an incident in 2017 when an otter bit a 5-year-old girl’s foot at Gardens by the Bay.

“They’ve been pampered an excessive amount of,” Ong mentioned.

The official mantra in Singapore is to look at the animals from a distance. Otters don’t react except they really feel threatened.


An official on the Nationwide Parks Board mentioned mitigation efforts, reminiscent of erecting obstacles, have been working.

“Most issues are simply solved,” mentioned Adrian Lavatory, who heads wildlife administration for the company.

Otter watchers reminiscent of Teo suppose the backlash has been overblown. Social media, he mentioned, is exhibiting extra sympathy for the animals. About 90% of Singaporeans stay in public housing, not the multimillion-dollar indifferent properties that may help fish ponds.


“It’s only a few loud voices that hold complaining,” Teo mentioned. “Mr. and Mrs. Know-It-All Singapore.”

With the coronavirus lockdown doubtless stretching into July, Teo and his cohorts are discovering it troublesome to maintain observe of the otters.

The final time the Zouk household was noticed was earlier this week, again within the Botanic Backyard.


“These guys are survivors, they’re explorers. It’s a completely new stage of inspiration,” mentioned Teo, 49, who ordinarily begins every day photographing otters at 6:30 a.m. earlier than heading to work.

“Sadly, I don’t suppose there’s any upside for them,” he added. “They’re simply going to maintain working round and crossing streets. When the circuit breaker eases up, vehicles are going to return to the highway. I’ve seen too many accidents.”

window.fbAsyncInit = function() ;

(function(d, s, id)(document, 'script', 'facebook-jssdk'));